Info Gov

The Independent Patient Choice and Procurement Panel has found that NHS Nottingham and Nottinghamshire Integrated Care Board acted lawfully in excluding Community Health and Eyecare Limited from a £4.6m community ophthalmology procurement for failing to upload a copy of its data protection impact assessment template. 

The Panel's report, reference CR0069-26 and dated 4 November 2026, was prepared by a case panel of the Panel's chair Andrew Taylor with Albert Sanchez-Graells and Sally Collier. It concerns the ICB's selection of a single provider for clinical triage, community assessment and treatment, cataract post-operative care and low vision aid services across Nottinghamshire, replacing three existing contracts.

Six providers bid. CHEC was one of three excluded at the basic selection stage, and on 22 June the ICB announced its intention to award the three-year contract, with a two-year extension option, to EMMS Healthcare Limited, the incumbent for Nottingham City.

CHEC's exclusion rested on question K.06 of the basic selection criteria, which asked bidders to confirm they were GDPR compliant and to attach a copy of their DPIA template at K.06a. A "Fail" was defined as answering "No", or answering "Yes" without providing a template, and any "Fail" on a pass/fail question meant exclusion.

CHEC answered "Yes" but uploaded nothing. Both evaluators marked the response a "Fail" with the comment "No DPIA provided". CHEC told the Panel the omission was a mistake, but argued it was a technical and documentary omission rather than a substantive failure of compliance, that the Atamis portal had tagged the upload field as "Optional" while the evaluation criteria made it mandatory, and that automatic exclusion was disproportionate when no concern had been raised about its actual GDPR compliance.

The Panel accepted the ICB's case that requesting DPIA templates on a pass/fail basis was standard practice across its competitive tenders and those of other commissioners supported by Arden and GEM Commissioning Support Unit, and that the ICB was cautious about self-certification in case a successful bidder later proved unable to produce a template during due diligence.

It found the approach proportionate "on balance", because templates "do have some value in demonstrating that bidders have a degree of process in place for DPIAs, even if this value may be limited". It added that the ICB's questions on data privacy "could have been framed in a way that gave the ICB more useful information and enabled a more robust assessment".

On the portal configuration, the Panel agreed with CHEC that tagging K.06a as "Optional" contradicted the evaluation criteria, since there was no circumstance in which a bidder could pass without the upload, and said it would have been "appropriate (and helpful)" to tag it as "Required". It nevertheless found the written instructions sufficiently clear, that bidders could not rely on portal tags to check completeness, and that the ICB was not responsible for CHEC's omission.

The tender documents stated that clarification could not be used to correct missing information, so the ICB was under no obligation to ask for the template. The Panel also rejected CHEC's suggestion that another bidder had been allowed to continue after initially failing the same requirement, finding no inconsistency of treatment.

The ICB did breach the Health Care Services (Provider Selection Regime) Regulations 2023 in three respects. It kept no record of the outcome of its Stage 1 compliance review and no contemporaneous record of its decision to stop evaluating CHEC's bid, contrary to the record-keeping duty in regulation 24.

It withheld its evaluators' scores and moderation notes on CHEC's key criteria responses on the basis that CHEC had failed the basic selection criteria "so not relevant/available", which the Panel said does not address the grounds for withholding in regulation 12(5); when asked how disclosure might prejudice commercial interests or fair competition, the ICB could say only that it had acted on legal advice. And it supplied the information it did release at the same time as its final decision on CHEC's representations, which the Panel said breaches the duty in regulation 12(4)(b) to respond promptly and the duty in 12(4)(a) to give the provider a further opportunity to explain its case, adding that it "has made numerous previous findings on this issue".

Because CHEC's exclusion was lawful, the Panel concluded the disclosure breaches made no difference to the outcome and advised the ICB to proceed with the award to EMMS. In a closing observation addressed to commissioners generally, it warned that "overly restrictive or unnecessarily prohibitive 'pass/fail' exclusionary criteria may have the effect of distorting or unduly narrowing the field of potential providers", making it harder to meet the duty under regulation 4(1)(a) to secure the needs of service users, improve quality and improve efficiency.

Also in this section

Nov 12, 2026

Schools' EdTech suppliers face certification scheme covering high-risk processing of pupil data

The Department for Education has opened a consultation on a certification scheme for educational technology and artificial intelligence products used in schools and other education settings in England, which would require suppliers of products that carry out high-risk processing of children's data to complete data protection impact assessments as a condition of certification.
Oct 19, 2026

ICO audit finds "limited" assurance over Derbyshire Constabulary data protection governance

The Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) has given Derbyshire Constabulary a "limited" assurance rating for governance and accountability following a consensual data protection audit, finding that the force does not hold a comprehensive record of processing activities and is not yet meeting the logging requirements for law enforcement processing under section 62 of the Data Protection Act 2018.