Info Gov

The Investigatory Powers Commissioner, Lord Leveson of Liverpool, has published his annual report for 2025, recording 366,976 warrants and authorisations across more than 600 public authorities and singling out MI5, the National Crime Agency, GCHQ, HM Prison and Probation Service and the Ministry of Defence for failures that he says "raised acute questions about compliance and candour".

Leveson said the case of Agent X, the MI5 covert human intelligence source at the centre of false evidence given to the High Court and the Investigatory Powers Tribunal, "is as serious as anything I have dealt with as Commissioner". The investigation, directed by the Prime Minister in September 2025 and led by the Deputy Commissioner Sir John Goldring, found that MI5 had told both courts that it had never departed from its neither-confirm-nor-deny stance over X's status, when an MI5 officer had confirmed it to a BBC journalist in June 2020.

The same false account was used in MI5's responses to IPCO's own 2022 inspection findings, leading the Commissioner to withdraw a finding against the agency. "Oversight depends on candour," Leveson said. "Failings of candour undermine the entire basis of oversight and accountability."

The report sets out four further areas of concern. The NCA's authorisation of a juvenile CHIS (Covert Human Intelligence Sources), the only such authorisation in 2025, was not notified to the Commissioner within the seven days required by the 2022 code of practice, and the agency could not consistently demonstrate that CHIS, undercover and other RIPA material was being reviewed, retained and disposed of correctly, which Leveson said fell well short of legal requirements.

GCHQ had still not established "a sufficiently clear understanding of the scale, location and recoverability" of lost removable media that may hold data obtained under the Investigatory Powers Act, several years after the issue was first raised. HMPPS showed recurring non-compliance with the Prison Rules in intercepting prisoners' communications and critical non-compliance in two areas of CHIS handling.

The MoD had not properly applied the Principles governing the detention and interviewing of detainees overseas. Leveson also reported problems at the Police Service of Northern Ireland in handling cases involving confidential material, consistent with the findings of Angus McCullough KC's independent review.

"None of these are minor administrative failings," he said, adding that he had raised each with the relevant leadership and "will not hesitate to report failure to demonstrate real improvement".

The Investigatory Powers Act 2016 requires the Commissioner to keep under review the use of investigatory powers by intelligence agencies, law enforcement, prisons, local authorities and other public bodies, with Judicial Commissioners approving warrants under the double lock and IPCO inspecting authorities' compliance. The Investigatory Powers (Amendment) Act 2024 introduced new safeguards during the reporting year, including the Part 7A and 7B regimes for bulk personal datasets.

Public authorities submitted 438 error and breach reports in 2025, of which 345 met the threshold and contained 690 individual errors; the UK intelligence community accounted for 586 of these, with GCHQ reporting 351 and MI5 211. Four met the definition of a serious error.

The report's annex of serious error investigations describes a suspect arrested and detained in a neighbouring force area after a digit was omitted from an online username, police searching the wrong properties after flawed analysis identified the wrong subscriber, and an innocent person arrested and detained and three generations of a family questioned after flawed IP data in two errors dating from 2023 that were only recognised in 2025.

Three further cases were referred to the Information Commission because telecommunications operators cannot commit relevant errors under the Act: a system change that produced 72 false positives and 88 false negatives in IP address resolutions and led to two innocent people being arrested, a one-hour GMT/BST time-zone mistake that led to an innocent caller being arrested, and a transposed address.

Communications data applications rose 8.7% to 349,097, an increase of 28,028 on 2024, continuing year-on-year growth since 2020 though at a slowing rate. IPCO's Office for Communications Data Authorisations authorised 316,961, returned 32,163 for rework and rejected 156; necessity was the most common reason for rework.

Prevention and detection of crime accounted for 275,429 authorisations, drug offences being the largest category at 28.5%, and preventing death or injury for 68,744. Law enforcement reported 1,280 of 1,591 communications data errors, most of them, the report says, human failings such as "a simple transposition of a number or letter".

Judicial Commissioners approved 3,524 targeted interception warrants and 3,471 targeted equipment interference warrants, refusing seven and 17 respectively, alongside 25 bulk interception, 37 bulk equipment interference and 16 bulk communications data warrants. There were 1,193 CHIS authorisations, 821 criminal conduct authorisations, up from 739, and 5,612 directed surveillance authorisations.

Nineteen communications data applications sought to identify a journalist's source, 67 warrant applications sought confidential journalistic material and 63 sought to identify a source. Of 116 requests to retain legally privileged material, 114 were approved.

GCHQ's own safeguards for privileged and journalistic material were found adequate, but a December 2025 review found "inadequate arrangements in respect of journalistic material" at one major overseas partner and surprisingly few partner requests for permissions under sections 153 and 154, which will be an inspection focus in 2026.

Local authorities accounted for 768 authorisations and were the subject of 114 inspections, with a further 53 of wider public authorities. IPCO observed high levels of compliance and found no instances of non-compliance requiring formal inclusion in the report.

Leveson said he remained satisfied that "independent oversight is working" and that leaders of public authorities showed a genuine commitment to compliance, while the test was whether "the commitment to compliance translates consistently into practice".

The annual report is at https://www.ipco.org.uk/publication/annua-report-2025/

Also in this section

Oct 14, 2026

Essex mental health trust admits implied consent to bedroom camera monitoring was wrong

Essex Partnership University NHS Foundation Trust has told the Lampard Inquiry that its approach to patient consent for the Oxevision camera monitoring system was wrong, after the inquiry heard that the system ran automatically on admission to certain wards and that requests from patients to switch it off could take up to 72 hours to consider.
Sep 09, 2026

Scottish Biometrics Commissioner urges ministers to replace 2011 CCTV strategy as consultation backs wider oversight remit

Scottish Biometrics Commissioner Dr Brian Plastow has called on Scottish ministers to replace the 2011 National Strategy for Public Space CCTV in Scotland, that the framework predates the modern digital era and that the government's current review of his remit, alongside the opportunity to introduce a Scottish surveillance camera code of practice, represents a once in a generation chance to act.