Info Gov

His Majesty's Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire & Rescue Services (HMICFRS) has found that oversight and safeguards for police use of retrospective facial recognition (RFR) are inconsistent and called for a clearer statutory framework, stronger national standards and improved governance of the technology.

The report, published on 12 November, examined how police forces in England and Wales and the National Crime Agency use RFR to compare images from sources such as CCTV, dashcams and social media against custody images held on the Police National Database (PND). It did not cover live or operator-initiated facial recognition.

HMICFRS makes 16 recommendations, which include:
• the Home Office introducing a requirement for a statutory code of practice by 30 June 2027;
• chief constables putting arrangements in place by 30 June 2027 to work with local communities and be open about how their forces use RFR;
• mandatory training by 31 December 2027 for all officers and staff involved in using RFR;
• clear national standards, and stronger national and local governance and oversight.

Inspectors found that some custody images which should have been deleted under existing retention rules remained available for facial recognition searches. The PND holds more than 20 million custody images, which forces upload whether or not the person arrested is charged or convicted. The report says national work is needed to improve compliance, strengthen image management and bring the treatment of custody images closer to that of other biometric data.

Forces carried out 291,341 retrospective searches in the year to 31 March 2026, with the number per force ranging from 611 to 29,742. HMICFRS found that forces did not use RFR consistently and that some investigators did not know that a potential match is intelligence rather than evidence and must be corroborated before enforcement action is taken.

In one force, more than half of the participants in a focus group were unaware of this, which the report describes as "deeply concerning". In a small number of cases officers relied too heavily on RFR results. One suspect was arrested in another force area over a series of shoplifting offences and transferred to the investigating force, where officers established that he did not match the image of the offender. In another force, inspectors were told that supervisors had directed officers to make an arrest on the basis of a potential match alone.

The report also records omissions in the auditting of RFR records. Forces are required to audit 1% of their RFR records, but National Police Chiefs' Council (NPCC) figures showed that only two forces had audited the correct number of files. Seven had not appointed an auditor, two auditors could not access the PND, ten forces had audited more than the required sample, and 22 either failed to submit a return or submitted incomplete information. Auditors identified cases where users had uploaded poor-quality or unsuitable probe images, including blurred images and images containing more than one face.

On bias, the report refers to National Physical Laboratory testing in 2024 which found that, at some settings, the algorithm was more likely to include women, Asian or Black people and people aged 21 to 29 in a list of potential matches. HMICFRS said a lack of data meant it could not establish with certainty whether this had contributed to any wrongful arrests. A new national algorithm procured by the Home Office has been trialled by Cheshire Constabulary and Essex Police, and the National Physical Laboratory found no significant differences in its performance between demographic groups.

There is no dedicated statute governing police use of facial recognition. Forces rely on common law policing powers, read with Part 3 of the Data Protection Act 2018, under which the processing of biometric data to identify an individual is sensitive processing that must be strictly necessary for a law enforcement purpose, together with Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights, the public sector equality duty and PACE Code D.

The retention of custody images has been in question since the High Court held in R (RMC and FJ) v Metropolitan Police Commissioner [2012] EWHC 1681 (Admin) that the indefinite retention of images of people who had not been convicted was unlawful. HMICFRS found that legislation has not kept pace with the technology, making it harder for forces to understand the lawful basis for RFR and the safeguards required.

Stone said the public generally supports the use of RFR but that forces must be able to show that safeguards are in place, that risks relating to bias and data retention are managed and that decisions remain subject to human judgment. She said a clearer statutory framework and stronger standards and oversight were "essential to maintaining public confidence".

Ben Russell, the NPCC lead on facial recognition, said policing remained committed to the ethical, proportionate and responsible use of RFR and welcomed the inspectorate's recognition of the technology's potential. Jasleen Chaggar of Big Brother Watch said the finding that officers were treating matches as evidence was alarming and criticised continued searching against custody images that she said were unlawfully held.

The inspection was based on fieldwork in March and April 2026 at the National Crime Agency and seven forces: British Transport Police, Cheshire, Dorset, Gwent, the Metropolitan Police, Northumbria and Surrey. It follows the publication in August of the Information Commissioner's Office's findings from consensual audits of police forces' use of facial recognition, and a Home Office commitment earlier this month to legislate on live facial recognition through the Police Reform Bill.

The HMICFRS announcement and report are available at: https://hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk/news/news-feed/police-forces-and-national-crime-agency-must-improve-oversight-of-retrospective-facial-recognition-to-maintain-public-confidence/

Also in this section

Nov 12, 2026

Oversight "depends on candour": Leveson names five bodies for compliance failures in 2025 annual report

The Investigatory Powers Commissioner, Lord Leveson of Liverpool, has published his annual report for 2025, recording 366,976 warrants and authorisations across more than 600 public authorities and singling out MI5, the National Crime Agency, GCHQ, HM Prison and Probation Service and the Ministry of Defence for failures that he says "raised acute questions about compliance and candour".
Oct 14, 2026

Essex mental health trust admits implied consent to bedroom camera monitoring was wrong

Essex Partnership University NHS Foundation Trust has told the Lampard Inquiry that its approach to patient consent for the Oxevision camera monitoring system was wrong, after the inquiry heard that the system ran automatically on admission to certain wards and that requests from patients to switch it off could take up to 72 hours to consider.
Sep 09, 2026

Scottish Biometrics Commissioner urges ministers to replace 2011 CCTV strategy as consultation backs wider oversight remit

Scottish Biometrics Commissioner Dr Brian Plastow has called on Scottish ministers to replace the 2011 National Strategy for Public Space CCTV in Scotland, that the framework predates the modern digital era and that the government's current review of his remit, alongside the opportunity to introduce a Scottish surveillance camera code of practice, represents a once in a generation chance to act.