Info Gov

The Information Commission has ruled that the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office (FCDO) was entitled to withhold briefing notes prepared for the then Middle East minister Hamish Falconer ahead of the Wilton Park conference on financing Gaza's reconstruction, but breached section 17(1) of the Freedom of Information Act 2000 by taking nearly three months to issue its refusal notice.

The request, made on 27 October 2025, asked for "briefing notes prepared for Hamish Falconer for the Wilton Park Conference in October". The UK had co-hosted the conference on Gaza's economic recovery and reconstruction with Egypt and the Palestinian Authority at Wilton Park on 13 October 2025, with Falconer opening it.

The FCDO did not respond until 21 January 2026, when it refused the request in full under sections 21, 27(1)(a), (b) and (c), 35(1)(a), 40(2) and 43(2).

Following an internal review completed on 19 March, it released a digest of the information, dropped its reliance on section 43(2), and maintained the remaining exemptions. The complainant went to the Commission on 21 April challenging the use of sections 27 and 35.

The decision notice, reference IC-505681-X5Y4 and dated 6 November 2026, upholds both exemptions and the section 40(2) redactions of junior officials' names, and requires no further steps. Sections 27(1)(a) to (c) exempt information whose disclosure would, or would be likely to, prejudice relations between the UK and other states or international organisations, or the UK's interests abroad.

Section 35(1)(a) exempts information held by a government department relating to the formulation or development of government policy. Both are qualified exemptions subject to the public interest test in section 2(2)(b).

The FCDO described the withheld material as detailed advice to ministers on the UK's approach to Gaza reconstruction, including sensitive assessments of political and economic conditions, policy options and material prepared for engagement with international partners. The conference had been run under the Wilton Park Procedure, a strengthened form of the Chatham House Rule, and the department argued that disclosing preparatory material from a confidential diplomatic forum would make partners less willing to engage candidly with the UK and impair its ability to convene such discussions.

The complainant argued that section 27 required harm to the interests of the UK as a whole rather than the FCDO's own international links, and that the exemption had been applied too broadly. The Commission accepted that disclosure would create a real and significant risk of prejudice to relations between the UK, "not simply the FCDO", and other states.

It found the material concerned sensitive and contentious issues about how Gaza's reconstruction would be financed, that the unattributed basis of the conference discussions was relevant even though the Wilton Park Procedure does not itself determine whether information is exempt, and that the request had been submitted less than a month after the conference while further work on the issues was ongoing. "The recent provenance of the withheld information arguably increases its sensitivity," the notice says.

On the public interest, the complainant pointed to what he called the exceptional circumstances of the subject matter, including a UN commission of inquiry's finding that genocide had been committed against Palestinians in Gaza, the International Criminal Court's arrest warrants for Benjamin Netanyahu, scrutiny of postwar plans for Gaza and the failures of schemes such as the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation.

The FCDO said it had addressed the public interest by proactively publishing Falconer's speech and the co-hosts' communiqué at the time. The Commission said it attached "considerable weight" to the factors favouring disclosure, since the withheld material would give significantly greater insight into the government's position than the published documents, but found that the interest in avoiding prejudice to international relations carried particular weight given the ongoing decision-making and the sensitive political context.

On section 35(1)(a), the complainant argued the FCDO's case amounted to a generic chilling effect argument about unspecified future policy debates, and that the Commission had been clear that ministers and advisers are expected to be robust. The Commission restated its position that civil servants are not easily deterred by the prospect of disclosure and that chilling effect arguments become more speculative once policy is finalised, but held that where policy is still live such arguments carry significant weight.

It accepted that policy-making on Gaza's reconstruction and its financing was ongoing at the time of the request, that disclosure would be likely to generate external commentary and pressure while ministers and officials were still considering options, and that the risk of a chilling effect was increased because releasing recent information on a live issue "could suggest that recent information on an ongoing policy issue could be released very soon after its creation".

The section 40(2) redactions covered the names and identifying details of junior officials involved in drafting the briefing who do not hold public-facing roles, which the Commission accepted as exempt in line with its section 40 guidance and previous decisions.

On procedure, the Commission found the FCDO breached section 17(1) by failing to issue its refusal notice within 20 working days of the 27 October request, having not responded until 21 January.

Also in this section

Nov 11, 2026

ICO serves university with information notice over FOI performance data after mailbox auto-reply blamed staffing

The Information Commission (ICO) has served an information notice on the University of Manchester under section 51 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000, giving the university 30 days to hand over 12 months of request-handling performance data it has repeatedly failed to provide, after the regulator found the university's information rights mailboxes returning an automated reply saying they were…
Nov 06, 2026

NHS England to require Palantir to clear FDP benefits claims after statistics watchdog intervention

NHS England chief executive Sir Jim Mackey has told the Parliamentary Health and Social Care Committee he will write to Palantir requiring it to share and clear with NHS England any future claims about the benefits of the Federated Data Platform, after the Office for Statistics Regulation (OSR) found that the organisation's own published figures could not establish that the platform caused the…
Sep 23, 2026

Redacted rights: When does Article 10 ECHR confer a right to information?

A three-judge panel of the Upper Tribunal (Lady Poole, UTJ Citron and UTJ Brewer) in Cruelty Free International v Information Commissioner & Home Office [2026] UKUT 328 (AAC) has held that Article 10 ECHR can, in narrow circumstances, confer a right to receive information from a public authority - but that this particular Appellant still cannot have any. Georgina Pein analyses the ruling.