Info Gov

The Information Commission has ordered Westminster City Council to issue fresh responses to three requests about the Pimlico District Heating Undertaking after finding that the council had not shown they were manifestly unreasonable under the Environmental Information Regulations 2004.

In a decision notice dated 5 November 2026 (IC-444038-G7Y8), the Commission found that the council had not demonstrated that regulation 12(4)(b) was engaged. The council must respond again within 30 calendar days without relying on the exception.

The requests were made on 4 and 5 August 2025. They sought costs and contractor quotations for boiler and heat exchanger works at Morgan House on the Lillington Gardens estate, supporting documentation for the "Do Nothing" cost estimate and borrowing assumptions in the project's Strategic Outline Case, and records of the decision to add two further options to the programme after that case was approved.

The council refused two of the requests under section 12 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000 in August and September 2025. A joint internal review on 28 October 2025 upheld those refusals and estimated that compliance would take about 33.25 hours. After the Commission asked it to reconsider under the EIR, the council issued a revised response on 6 August 2026 refusing all three requests under regulation 12(4)(b) on grounds of cost and diversion of resources. It confirmed it was not arguing that the requests were vexatious.

Regulation 12(4)(b) allows a public authority to refuse a request for environmental information that is manifestly unreasonable, subject to the public interest test. The EIR set no fixed cost limit, and the Commission said the appropriate limit under FOIA is a reference point only. The unreasonableness must be obvious or clear, and the authority must give a supported explanation of the burden and how it was estimated.

The council told the Commission that the three requests together contained 32 items, described the searching, review and redactioninvolved, and pointed to the volume of other requests it had received about the heating scheme. The Commission said the number of items did not measure how many records were held or how long they would take to process, and that breadth alone did not establish manifest unreasonableness. The council had supplied no quantified estimate, sampling exercise or breakdown, and the 33.25-hour figure covered only two of the requests and came with no explanation of how it was calculated.

The Commission noted that the EIR contain no equivalent of the FOIA aggregation rules but said it did not need to decide whether aggregation was justified, because the burden had not been evidenced even taking the requests together. Requests received in 2026 could not show the burden of requests made in August 2025, and the Commission made no finding that the complainant was part of a coordinated campaign. The council had also not shown why the extension for complex and voluminous requests under regulation 7 could not reduce the burden.

The Commission said its conclusion was not that compliance would be easy, but that the council had failed to evidence its case. As the exception was not engaged, it did not go on to consider the public interest.

Under other matters, the Commission told the council to check dates and references carefully, after the council gave 2026 dates for requests made in 2025. It also recorded that the complainant had offered to contribute to the cost, and said authorities are under no obligation to provide information at cost or to work up to the point at which a request becomes manifestly unreasonable.
Either party may appeal to the First-tier Tribunal within 28 days.

Also in this section

Nov 11, 2026

ICO serves university with information notice over FOI performance data after mailbox auto-reply blamed staffing

The Information Commission (ICO) has served an information notice on the University of Manchester under section 51 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000, giving the university 30 days to hand over 12 months of request-handling performance data it has repeatedly failed to provide, after the regulator found the university's information rights mailboxes returning an automated reply saying they were…
Nov 11, 2026

FCDO entitled to withhold briefing on Gaza reconstruction, Information Commission rules

The Information Commission has ruled that the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office (FCDO) was entitled to withhold briefing notes prepared for the then Middle East minister Hamish Falconer ahead of the Wilton Park conference on financing Gaza's reconstruction, but breached section 17(1) of the Freedom of Information Act 2000 by taking nearly three months to issue its refusal notice.
Nov 06, 2026

NHS England to require Palantir to clear FDP benefits claims after statistics watchdog intervention

NHS England chief executive Sir Jim Mackey has told the Parliamentary Health and Social Care Committee he will write to Palantir requiring it to share and clear with NHS England any future claims about the benefits of the Federated Data Platform, after the Office for Statistics Regulation (OSR) found that the organisation's own published figures could not establish that the platform caused the…